Rogue National Park Service Twitter account says its no longer run by government employeesbut maybe it never was
The rogue government Twitter account, AltUSNatParkService,which claimed it was being run by current park rangers, says it has now handed off control of its Twitter account to several activists and journalists who believe they can continue in the same spirit.
The move has led some to question if the account was, in fact, ever operated by disgruntled government employees in the first place and, if it was, whether or not itjust squandered the power the account held to serve as a means of resisting the Trump administration.
If you havent been following closely, the saga of the rogue government Twitter accounts can be a little confusing.
This week,the Trump administrationissued gag orders affecting several government agencies, including the Environmental Protection Agency, the Department of Agriculture, the Department of Health and Human Services and the Interior Department, which oversees the National Park Service. The orderslimited the agencies ability to communicate with the public, including through social media postings.
But one official National Park Service account, @BadlandsNPS(Badlands National Park), seemed to be taking a stand against the new administration. The account was tweeting facts about climate change, apparentlyin defiance of President Trumps position on the matter.
When those tweetswere later deleted, the public cried that government censorship was at hand.
The National Park Service, however, issued a statement that explained the tweets had been posted by a former employee who was not supposed to be authorized to use the parks account:
The park was not told to remove the tweets but chose to do so when they realized their account had been compromised. At this time, National Park Service social media managers are encouraged to continue the use of Twitter to post information relating to public safety and park information, with the exception of content related to national policy issues.
Not everyone bought this explanation, naturally.
READ Key ballot measures: The important, the fascinating and the weird
Powered by Inline Related Posts
Soon thereafter, rogue government Twitter accounts representing the oppressed agencies started to appear.
The first and most infamous was @AltNatParkSer (AltUSNatParkService), which tweeted defiantly: Cant wait for President Trump to call us FAKENEWS. You can take our official twitter, but youll never take our free time!
The account claimed to be run by park rangers, but said they couldnt identify themselves.
we do not feel it is safe or in the public interest to identify ourselves. We have been advised of this by [several] journalists, the account tweeted on Wednesday.
The whole thingmakes for a goodstory, and one which its all too easy to envision: people who have dedicated their lives to protecting the earth, forced into silence by their government, leaving them no choice but to anonymously begin tweeting the truth.
Yet, there has never been proof that @AltNatParkSer was ever run by disgruntled government employees. Journalists tried, and failed, to confirm this. And now, the account says it has handed itself off to activists and journalists, which justseemsodd.
First of all, ifthese employees felt so strongly about defying Trump, why ditch the account now that it has worldwide attention? Wouldnt that have beenthe end goal? And who are these reporters supposedly working with the activists instead of just coveringthem?
And why does an account thats now supposedlyrun by former scientists need to employ journalists for fact checking? Are scientists capable of that? Isnt factual informationthe point of science?
There are a lot of questions here, and still too few answers.
READ Police injured, more than 200 arrested at Trump inauguration protests in DC
Powered by Inline Related Posts
For what its worth, theaccount claims they hadgrown fearful of criminal prosecution, because theywere using the NPAs official logo.
Its just as reasonable, though, to assume that the original account holders were fearful that theymay end up beingexposed as mereactivists, notdefiantgovernment workers.
After all, the account never verified itself through Twitter or any other trusted third-party such as through one of thesesupposedjournalist partners, or a trusted, independent organization like EFF, as wassuggestedby VICEs Motherboard.
And when pressed about its lack of verification, it got a little snippy:
Despite thelack of proof, many took the account at its word because its existence fits a certain narrative.
To further confuse the matter, the popularity of @AltNatParkSer prompted a wave of other Alt government accountsto appear.
Suddenly we had@BadHombreNPS, @AltMtRainierNPS, @RogueNASA, @AltForestServ, @AltHHS, @Alt_FDA,@ActualEPAFacts, @AltUSDA,@AlternativeNWSand others to track.
Some of these also claim to be run by government employees, while others explicitly saidthey arenot. Others say theyre operated by a combination of employees and activists, and some say nothing about their creators at all.
Some are nowdownplaying any official affiliation, orsayingtheyre going to change their logo from their (illegally used) official one. In fact, @AltMtRainierNPS just asked Twitter if doing so would help itget verified. (Twitter didnt respond.)
Another, @AlternativeNWS, says its also trying to hand off its account to non-government people for safety.
As these accounts are supposedly transferred, many Twitter users are thanking them for being so brave, strong and defiant. Unfortunately, we have no proof that any government employees ever actually took a stand. We only have the anonymous accounts word, and were being asked to believe on faith.
While the spirit of resistance is certainly understandable, the emergence of rogue government Twitter has onlyled to a lot of confusion.
Itdoesnt help the resistance to further blur the line between truth and fact. It doesnt help ifthe media reports an anonymous Twitter accounts story as being fact, whenthe source isnt verified.
And it doesnt help for there now to be a plethora of government-esque accounts being run by a range of unidentified parties tweeting things they want everyone to believe are facts.